58 Comments

Here is a little video of the hotel then and now. At 0:59 there’s a grainy photo of the original monument. Google brings up no other works by this artist. Ironic that it lasted less than 20 years, but is immortalized by Hemingway, who doesn’t even describe it. https://youtu.be/xhLNQK69xoM

Expand full comment

If you squint, you can see the cat!

Expand full comment

As a journalist, Hemingway would've been impressed by your sleuthing, Mia. I know I am!

Expand full comment

This is yet another example of how this class rounds out the learning experience in new and fascinating ways. Thank you for sharing.

Expand full comment

Oh wow, my family lives in a nearby town, Chiavari. I have to check out the hotel in the summer!

Expand full comment

Story Club field trip? George would get room 66.

Thanks Mia, I even enjoyed feebly prolonging the story via the hotel reviews ("The staff are friendly and very helpful especially Lorenzo who was very informative and nothing was too much trouble." "The gentleman who looks after the desk is very good man and

very helpful specially for the vegetarian people.")

Expand full comment

The first statue is erected to memorialize "Brotherly soldiers in the supreme sacrifice, gloriously joined, in the greatest Italian victory", and then "melted down for military hardware" in the next war less than two decades later. That seems like the core of a flash fiction story.

Expand full comment

I love this shirt summation and interpretation of the story. It's in the link in the ascent. Thank you, Mia.

"As the central trope of "Cat in the Rain" the war monument is a mute reminder of the incomplete lives toward which the narrative's modalities point. Indeed, this concise little tale of a woman's thwarted yearnings coincides with the aborted dreams memorialized in the sculptures--both the "American girl" and the "fallen" Italian soldiers have been robbed of the natural fulfillment life might be expected to hold"

Expand full comment

What brilliant sleuthing, thanks, Mia. I'm with Vibeke – wouldn't it be great to have a Story Club tour of places like this?

Expand full comment

For another take on this relationship, try reading "The Paris Wife" by Paula McLain, a fictional memoir of Hemingway's first wife, Hadley Richardson.

Expand full comment

One day maybe , we make a George Saunders Story Club excursion to that hotel

Expand full comment
Jan 3, 2022·edited Jan 3, 2022

Thanks for finding and sharing this Mia. Inspiring to see the real view from the room in the video and think how Hemingway made a story partly from his experience at this hotel. While it’s fascinating in itself, it also somehow gives me hope in the opportunities that are open to us to include the specificity of real life in writing our fiction.

Expand full comment

Fantastic! Thank you so much for sharing

Expand full comment

It is so much--though a bit grander--as I pictured it, with the palms prominent. A great pre-war building.

Expand full comment

Very impressive research!

Expand full comment